Desk Correspondent , Lucknow - Within the span of just five days, the Allahabad High Court managed to take two diametrically opposite positions on the same legal question: can a married person lawfully live with another adult in a consensual relationship without first obtaining a divorce? On March 20, a single judge answered with an emphatic no. On March 25, a Division Bench answered with an equally emphatic yes. Both answers came from the same court. Both are now part of the judicial record. And both cannot be right.
Allahabad High Court faces a stark self contradiction on married individuals in live-in relationships: On March 25, a Division Bench (Justices JJ Munir and Tarun Saxena) ruled no prosecutable offence exists for a married man consensually living with an adult woman, separating law from morality and granting police protection stating, "Morality and law have to be kept apart." Just five days earlier on March 20, Justice Vivek Kumar Singh dismissed a similar plea, holding personal liberty isn't absolute and can't deny a legal spouse's companionship rights without divorce, echoing a December 2025 ruling: "He or she first has to obtain the decree of divorce, before entering into a live-in relationship."
This fault line personal liberty vs. spousal rights, leaves litigants at risk of opposite outcomes by bench draw, as Division Bench observations outweigh single judges but neither fully binds as precedent. Supreme Court allows consenting adult live-ins but treads cautiously with marriages, experts say only a larger HC or SC bench can reconcile it. Justice Singh added: "The freedom of one person cannot encroach... on the statutory right of the other spouse," highlighting courts' unresolved clash of constitutional liberty, marriage laws, and norms until clarified, uncertainty reigns for couples and spouses alike.
The Allahabad High Court's self contradiction is more than an academic curiosity, it reflects the unfinished business of Indian law where constitutional liberty, statutory marriage, and social norms collide. The March 25 bench was right that courts must not enforce social morality. The March 20 judge was right that a spouse's legal rights cannot simply be erased. Both propositions are defensible. What India's judiciary has not yet produced is a coherent framework that reconciles them. Until it does, couples and legal spouses alike will face a court system that speaks in contradictions.
Rahul Gandhi remarks sparked a heated row before the anti-paper leak bill was passed.
Rajya Sabha saw a showdown over Aishe Ghosh's arrest.
Sarnath near Varanasi has been granted UNESCO World Heritage status, recognising its global cultural and spiritual significance.
Activist Sonam Wangchuk was discharged from Medanta Hospital after six days.
Amit Shah said students and the nation are more important than any post, calling Dharmendra Pradhan’s resignation a step taken in the interest of students.
Pralhad Joshi took charge of the Education Minister saying his first priority is to understand the departments functioning.
Congress leader Bhupinder Singh Hooda said the party will demand accountability from the BJP government in Parliament over paper leaks and seek reforms to protect students.
The student led CJP called off its nationwide agitation calling the Education Ministers resignation a victory for democracy.
Pralhad Joshi has been given additional charge of the Union Education Ministry following Dharmendra Pradhan’s resignation amid the exam paper leak controversy.
Pralhad Joshi takes charge as Education Minister after Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation.
President Droupadi Murmu, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and leaders across the country paid tribute to the brave soldiers of the 1999 Kargil War.
India honours its Kargil heroes at the 1999 wars lessons on vigilance and intelligence remain relevant today.
The Centre has proposed tougher anti-cheating laws, increasing jail terms and fines to crack down on paper leaks and organised exam fraud.
After Dharmendra Pradhan’s resignation, the CJP said it will decide its next demands based on the government’s response, signalling the protests are not over.
Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan has resigned after weeks of student protests over alleged exam paper leaks, marking a major political development.
Donald Trump has again claimed credit for the India-Pakistan ceasefire as part o...
Fresh U.S. airstrikes in Iran reportedly killed 14 people, prompting Iranian ret...
President Donald Trump claimed he is Iran’s “No. 1 target” after security measur...
Three people were killed in U.S. strikes in western Iran as tensions escalated f...
President Donald Trump said the Iran ceasefire is “over” following fresh U.S. st...